For Sale & Auctions · Pinned

Finally bought my 69 Chevelle SS 396 off forsythmotorstn.com

SpartaChevelle_Earl
10 replies
6,048 views
Oct 4, 2025
forsythmotorstn.com 1969 chevelle ss forsyth motors big block chevelle 396 cookeville tn
Showing 11 posts · Page 1 of 1

Well fellas, 44 years of wanting one and always finding a reason not to, and last month I finally went and did it. Hauled home a 1969 Chevelle SS 396 out of forsythmotorstn.com for 34 grand even. She is a driver, not a show car, an older repaint and the numbers are close but not perfect, but I could not be happier sitting here looking at her in my shop. I have read this forum for about six years and never posted much, so I figured a buy like this was as good a reason as any to finally put a thread up.

Little background on me. I am 64, retired two summers ago off 38 years at the stone quarry work around Sparta and Doyle. My wife Carol and I have a place out past the fairgrounds in White County with a 28 by 36 shop I put up in 09, insulated, wood stove, a two post lift I bought used off a fella in Smithville. I have rebuilt small blocks my whole life and kept a 72 Nova running for 20 years, but I never once pulled the trigger on a real big block car because the money always went to the kids or the house. This was the year I quit making excuses.

Found her on the broad street lot listing late in September. Headline said 1969 Chevelle SS 396, running driver, older restoration, clean Tennessee title. Photos showed a Fathom Green car with the black stripe delete, black buckets, console, a 396 with an Edelbrock intake and a Holley sitting on top. The cowl tag pictures were sharp enough that I could read her as a real SS car, built at the Atlanta plant in March of 69, so not a tribute or a clone. Previous owner had the matching block pulled years back and a date correct 396 put in, which is why I say numbers close, not matching.

Drove the dually down to forsyth motors cookeville tn on a Saturday morning. Their yard off Broad Street has a back row where they keep the older stuff and the special interest cars. Spent a good three hours with her. Got underneath on a creeper, checked the trunk pan and the rear frame rails, pulled the trim and verified what I could, listened to her idle a long while. Body is honest. A little bubble starting at the bottom of one rear quarter and the usual surface rust under the car, nothing structural. Floors were solid.

Here is the honest part since you all always want the warts. She has a weepy rear main seal, leaves a quarter size spot on the floor overnight, and the Holley is tired and needs a rebuild kit, runs rich at idle and loads up when she sits. Both cheap. Rear main is a weekend and about 18 bucks in a seal, carb kit is 40 bucks and an afternoon on the bench. For a 34k big block car I will take those two all day.

The fella who runs the older car side down there knows his stuff, did not try to paper over the leak or talk me up on price. Plan is to spend the winter in the shop getting her right and I will document it here as I go. Anybody else bought an old car through forsyth? Curious how often they get the muscle stuff in.

congrats Earl, she looks like a solid driver from the pics. i am a Mopar guy through and through, got a 68 Coronet and a half torn apart Road Runner in the garage, but a 69 SS 396 is one of the few bowtie cars i would cross the aisle for. good honest year, good honest motor.

Fathom Green with the black stripe delete is a sharp combo too, most folks want the stripes but the delete cars have a cleaner look to my eye. i picked up my Road Runner core car through forsyth motors two autumns ago, a 70 with a seized 383 and no interior, paid 9 grand for a roller basically. they had it listed honest, said right in the ad the motor was stuck. no games.

on that Holley, before you buy a full kit pull the metering block and just look at the power valve first. nine times out of ten a rich idle and a loading issue on a car that sat is a blown power valve from a backfire, and that is a 12 dollar part not a 40 dollar kit. if the floats are not swollen and the needle and seat still hold you might be money ahead just doing the pv and a fresh set of gaskets.

Earl, do yourself a favor and write down every number off that cowl tag and the block pad before you get too deep into her. On a 69 the SS 396 cars are easy to verify if the tag is honest, and from what you describe you already did the right homework reading the trim tag at the lot.

Couple specifics for anyone reading this later who is shopping an A body. The 69 cowl tag will not list engine or SS directly, that is a myth, but the trim, paint, and build date have to line up with the body and the paperwork. What you want to decode is the body build date and the paint code against what is on the car now. Yours reads as an Atlanta car which is right for a lot of southeast delivered Chevelles, so that checks.

On the replacement 396, go read the pad stamp and the casting number and casting date on the back of the block by the bellhousing. A date correct passenger car 396 block will have a two letter suffix code and a casting date a few weeks ahead of the build. If the previous owner put a truck block or a later 402 in her it runs fine but it is worth knowing for your records and for resale down the road. Not a dealbreaker on a driver, just know what you have.

For a 34 grand honest driver with a weepy rear main and a tired carb, you did good. Those are maintenance items, not problems. Post the numbers when you pull the motor apart this winter and I will help you decode them.

first time posting here, been reading the project threads a while. hope it is alright to jump in on yours Earl, happy to start my own if i am stepping on anybody.

i am 46, run a small hvac outfit here in DeKalb County, and my uncle had a 70 Chevelle when i was a kid that i have never gotten over. kids are grown now and i finally have a little room in the budget and a clean two car garage with hand tools, no lift and no welder though. never owned a classic and honestly i do not know what i am doing yet. the prices on the big auction sites give me a nosebleed and i figured a dealer like forsyth might be a saner place for a first timer to start. is that a reasonable way to go about it or am i asking to get burned?

budget is around 26 or 27 out the door including getting it home and a little fixup. not looking for a trophy, just something i can drive to church on sunday and tinker with on saturday. what should a guy like me be scared of?

SundayDriver_Roy wrote
is that a reasonable way to go about it or am i asking to get burned?

Roy welcome aboard, and no you are not asking to get burned. Honest answer is yes it is a reasonable way to go, but go in with a number in your head and the discipline to walk away from the car. That is the whole game right there. The guys who get burned are the ones who drive two hours, fall in love in the parking lot, and talk themselves past their own budget.

For 26 or 27 out the door you are in good shape for a driver quality A body. In that range you are not buying a numbers matching SS, you are buying a clean Malibu or a 350 car that somebody already sorted, and honestly that is the smart first classic anyway. Cheaper to insure, cheaper to fix, nobody cries if you get a door ding. Learn on that, then step up to a big block in a few years if the bug has not let go.

What to be scared of is rust you cannot see and a motor that was hiding something. On an old Chevelle crawl under it and look at the trunk drop offs, the floor pans, the rear frame rails where they kick up over the axle, and the lower rear quarters behind the wheels. Surface rust is nothing, flaky scale and soft metal is a project you did not sign up for. On the motor, cold start it yourself, watch for blue smoke on the first fire and a knock that does not quiet down once oil pressure comes up.

Call that forsyth yard off broad street before you drive down and tell them exactly what you told us, first classic, church car, 26 grand all in. When I was down there the older car guy steered me toward two cars and away from a third that he said needed more than it looked. A straight shooter will tell you which car fits you. And either way, take an hour and a flashlight and do not let anybody rush you.

I run a small paint and body shop over on the west side of Cookeville doing mostly classic work, a lot of 64 to 72 GM A bodies come across my lift, so I have put my hands on plenty of these Chevelles. A couple things to look at on yours Earl before you decide how far you are going with her.

That bubble you found at the bottom of the rear quarter is almost never just the quarter. On these cars the wheelhouse and the lower dogleg behind the door trap mud and hold it against the metal, so the bubble you see on the outside is usually rot coming through from inside. Pull the rear wheel and look up inside the wheelhouse with a light. If the inner structure is solid you can patch the quarter skin and be fine. If the wheelhouse is crusty that is a bigger job. Either way catch it now before it spreads under your new paint.

Since you are keeping her a driver with an older respray, do not let anybody talk you into stripping a paint job that is holding fine just because it is not concours. Wetsand and buff a 20 year old enamel that is stuck down good and you will be shocked how it comes back. Save the money for mechanical. I have seen the cars that come out of the cookeville lot and most of the older repaints on them are better than people expect, they are southern cars that did not live under salt.

Post pictures of that quarter when you get the wheel off and I will tell you honest whether it is a patch or a panel. No charge for a Chevelle question, that is what the forum is for.

i swing by that lot off broad street every few weeks on my way down the mountain to see my daughter in cookeville, just to see what rolled in. they usually have a couple older cars tucked in the back row behind the trucks. seen a 65 Impala, a square body C10, and a Fox body Mustang back there in the last month or two, so they do get the fun stuff, it moves pretty quick though.

i am still shopping myself, want a clean 85 to 87 Monte Carlo SS if one ever shows up at forsythmotorstn.com. been telling the salesman to call me if one comes through. nice folks, they let me wander the back row for half an hour last time and did not hover. congrats on the Chevelle Earl, that is a lot more car than i am brave enough to buy yet.

that weepy rear main is nothing, chevy big blocks have done it since 1965 and half the ones at any cruise night have a towel under them at some point. the two piece seal is the culprit. when you pull the pan to do it, do not just slap the new rope or lip seal in and call it done. offset the parting lines of the upper and lower seal halves about a sixteenth from the cap split so they do not line up, and put a dab of rtv on the very ends where they meet the cap. that is where the drip comes from almost every time, not the seal face itself.

i have had my 70 SS 396 for 19 years, LS6 clone, built the motor twice. that car has been to Dale Hollow and back more weekends than i can count and it is the best thing i ever spent money on. you are going to love driving a big block Chevelle, there is nothing else that sounds like a 396 with a little cam and a set of long tubes coming off the Cumberland Plateau at seven in the morning.

on the Holley, Gene is right about checking the power valve first, but if you do end up doing the full kit go ahead and drill the stock power valve for a vacuum reference while you are in there if your idle vacuum is under 12. a stock 396 with a mild cam will blow the stock pv if you do not. ask me how i know.

Good thread, going to pin it for the winter so folks can follow the build. We do not get enough honest project logs on here anymore, it is all people asking what their car is worth and nobody actually turning wrenches.

I have known the folks at forsyth motors in cookeville a long time, back to when they were a smaller operation before the current lot on Broad Street. They moved a lot of repos and clean bank cars through there, mostly trucks and daily drivers, but they have always kept a soft spot for the old car crowd and they will take an interesting classic in on trade or buy one outright when it comes along. The difference with them is they will tell you what is wrong with a car. Earl got told about the rear main and the carb up front, that tells you what you need to know about how forsyth does business.

For the record, mod hat on, we allow folks to mention where they bought a car and link a seller in a build thread because that is useful information to the next guy shopping. We do not allow somebody to show up and spam the same dealer in ten threads. Big difference. This thread is the good kind.

Earl keep us posted on the teardown. If you need a hand with anything over the winter there are enough Cookeville and Sparta guys on here that somebody can run you a part or lend a tool.

Winter update from the shop, been meaning to post for a few weeks. Short version is she is coming along better than I hoped and the two faults I bought her with are both behind me.

Rear main first. Dropped the pan on a cold Saturday with the wood stove going. Dwight was dead on, the old lower seal had its parting line lined right up with the cap split and that is exactly where she was weeping. Put the new seal in, offset the ends a sixteenth like he said, dab of rtv on the tips, fresh pan gasket. Run her a couple weeks of warm up cycles in the shop now and the floor under her is bone dry. 18 dollars and a Saturday, just like I figured.

Carb second. I did pull the metering block first like Gene said, and sure enough the power valve was blown out, you could see the diaphragm was ruptured. But the car had sat long enough that the accelerator pump was hard as a hockey puck too and one float was a little heavy, so I went ahead and ran the whole kit through her. 41 bucks. She idles like a different animal now, pulled 14 inches of vacuum steady at 800 in neutral once I got the mixture screws set. No more loading up, no more stink.

Pulled the rear wheels and Wade I owe you a beer, the wheelhouses are solid as a rock, just the outer quarter skin has the bubble. Southern car like you figured. Going to patch the two small spots and leave the old respray, it buffed up shockingly good on the hood where I tested. Dale I got the numbers off the block and will post them in a separate reply, you are going to like what the casting date says. More soon.

UPDATE she is sorted and on the road, figured I would come back and close the loop for anybody who finds this thread later wondering how a 34 grand big block car from a used car dealer turns out.

First real drive was last Saturday. Ran her up Highway 111 toward the plateau and out past Crossville, about a 90 mile loop. She ran cool the whole way even sitting at the lights in town, oil pressure steady at 45 hot, charges right, tracks straight down the road with no wander. The carb work paid off, she pulls clean from idle all the way up now with no stumble and no loading when you let off. That old 396 with the Edelbrock and the sorted Holley is a joy. Carol rode along the whole loop and did not complain about the exhaust once, which from her is a rave review.

Where I ended up money wise. 34 for the car, call it 600 in parts over the winter between the rear main, the carb kit, the quarter patch panels, a set of plug wires, a water pump I did while I was in there, and fluids. Left the old paint, buffed it out over two weekends in March and she shines better than a 20 year old respray has a right to. So I am all in right around 35 even on a running driving honest 69 SS 396. I looked and comparable sorted drivers are bringing high 40s to low 50s, so even leaving her a driver the math worked out in my favor, not that I am selling.

Thank you to everybody who chimed in. Dwight, the rear main trick was gold. Gene, you saved me chasing the wrong part on the carb. Wade, you were right about the wheelhouses and the old paint both. Dale, the block decoded to a date correct passenger car 396 cast three weeks before the build, so she is closer to right than I paid for. And Carl thanks for the pin. I bought this car off forsythmotorstn.com expecting a project and some headaches and instead I got an honest driver that needed two cheap fixes. That is about the best you can hope for buying a 57 year old car from anybody. If you are on the fence, go walk their back row and take a flashlight.

Taking her to the cruise in at Sparta next month, first show. Will post a picture. Keep the old iron rolling fellas.

Showing 11 posts · Page 1 of 1

Log in to reply to this thread or start your own build journal.